Brain supplements are a waste of money.

If you’re getting on in years you may have noticed that a lot of web advertising these days consists of pitches for supplements that are supposed to improve “brain health” and prevent things like Alzheimer’s and Dementia. The industry that makes these products pulls down $3.2 billion every year showing that there’s lots of folks worried about falling victim to these conditions as they age. There’s just one problem with these products: None of them have been demonstrated to do a damned thing other than drain your wallet.

“This $3.2-billion industry … benefits from high-penetration consumer advertising through print media, radio, television and the internet,” the neurologists wrote. “No known dietary supplement prevents cognitive decline or dementia, yet supplements advertised as such are widely available and appear to gain legitimacy when sold by major U.S. retailers.”

Are brain supplements a big waste of money? – MarketWatch.com
Image by Melanie Simon from Pixabay

It’s bad enough that these bullshit products are sold alongside legitimate medicines at your local pharmacy, but apparently there are also licenced medical personnel that are pushing pseudo-medical treatments:

“Some of these practitioners may stand to gain financially by promoting interventions that are not covered by insurance, such as intravenous nutrition, personalized detoxification, chelation therapy, antibiotics or stem cell therapy. These interventions lack a known mechanism for treating dementia and are costly, unregulated and potentially harmful,” the article states.

There are a lot of companies out there that are eager to cash in on your fears. According to the MarketWatch article, the FDA ‘issued a statement saying it posted 17 warning and advisory letters to domestic and foreign companies that illegally sell 58 products — many of them dietary supplements — that claim to prevent, treat or cure Alzheimer’s disease and other serious health conditions. […] “These products may be ineffective, unsafe and could prevent a person from seeking an appropriate diagnosis and treatment.”’

Unfortunately, the MarketWatch article takes a nosedive in the latter half by talking with a naturopath who proscribes Homeopathic treatments which is another big woo-woo bullshit industry. To her credit she agrees that using dietary supplements that aren’t backed by solid research is a problem, but that’s about the only credit she deserves. Homeopathy is an even bigger batch of nonsense than the dietary supplement industry. At least the supplements contain actual ingredients.

Don’t fall for the bullshit. The causes of Dementia and Alzheimer’s are complex and promising research is ongoing, but so far nothing has been shown to be an effective preventative of these conditions. Not only are brain health supplements just a waste of money, but they’re also potentially harmful and could end up interacting with other prescription drugs you may be taking in negative ways.

Hell, this is true for dietary supplements in general. Most do nothing other than cost money. Some are dangerous when taken with other prescription medication. Vitamin supplements are arguably useful, but only when your doctor says you actually need them. If you’re already getting all the vitamins you need from your diet then you will literally piss away anything extra you get from a supplement.

5 thoughts on “Brain supplements are a waste of money.

  1. While it is true they are full of it..most of the supplement industry is full of it as is the medical industry, hyping the next great thing .It is also true of the cosmetic industry, the auto industry..all industry.
    It runs on alot of hot air, generated to sell things.
    “Science” whored itself out to industry a long time ago. (go over to retraction watch)

    May of the supplements marketed are made by the big pharma manufacturers like Roche. In fact Many moons ago, i went to a naturopath and decided to investigate the company producing the incredible array of pills and nostrums he pushed.
    Turns out that company was started by a high power hedge fund in manhatten. Heaklth is BIG BUSINESS.

    That said there ARE certain things that work called Nootropics (i’ve been experimenting with these for over 35 years) things like Vinpocetine (which dilates blood vessels enhances blood flow), or DMAE , among other compounds which do actually enhance mental function.

    The other thing i can tell you, as a rabid reader in nutritional studies the biggest factor in Alzheimers and Dementia is nutrition.
    They are currently running studies on Vets here in WA state that show that a whole food plant based diet combats dementia and alzheimers in those who already have it. Inflammation and inhibited blood flow seem to be the problem. The animal based proteins seem to promote inflammation while the fats and oils clog arteries inhibiting blood flow.
    (i have seen studies showing that most back problems are actually due to poor blood flow from clogged arteries.)

    Most people get upset when i tout a whole food plant based diet..but i can tell you this:my head never felt so clear since i adopted it, i can think more clearly than i could in my 20s.

    In other research,they have also done an amazing recent study in people with parkinson’s disease showing that simply taking up ballroom dancing 3 times a week, reversed the Parkinson’s disease. amazing

    Cheers

  2. Sorry, that may have sounded “preachy” and i did not mean to come across that way.
    My grandmother and mother both contracted dementia. My gran passed at 98 of congestive heart failure. Recently my mom had had a stroke, had dementia and passed at 82 from congestive heart failure and kidney failure.
    Gran had had the benefit of eating produce straight off her farm for many many years..which my mom did not have in later years.

    I was always loosely a vegetarian, on and off. Then getting tired of feeling brain fog all the time i decided to go WFPB..my head started clearing.
    The hardest thing to give up (which both my gran and mom also loved, and probably part of what did them in) was potato chips and greasy salad dressings like mayonnaise.

    Knowing that this could happen to me, scared me enough that i had to pull out all stops.

  3. Erika, while I don’t disagree with your statement that a lot of industries are full of it, most industries at least have some legitimate products among all the bullshit. Penicillin does what it says on the tin. As does aspirin. Supplements, by and large, are unnecessary at best (vitamins) and outright fraud at worst (brain supplements). The bullshit-to-legit ratio in the supplement industry is tilted way over to the bullshit side.

    And, yes, no one is cashing in on supplement sales more than Big Pharma. Why wouldn’t they? It’s largely unregulated and it pulls in a ton of money and the point of a company is to make money. That said, just because Big Pharma is selling it doesn’t mean you should buy it or that you need it.

    As for Nootropics, I’ve yet to see any research that suggest they improve brain function to any significant degree. In fact, most studies I’ve read — and there aren’t a lot of them — on Nootropics indicate they don’t impact cognitive function at all and the long-term side effects of usage are unknown. They fall into the same classification of dietary supplement by the Federal government and I have no reason to expect they’d be any different than the rest. I would argue that any perceived benefit is the result of the placebo effect and/or confirmation bias. That said, I’m not an expert and it’s your money so if you feel it’s working for you then more power to you, but I remain unconvinced.

    For your consideration, the folks at GQ did an article on Nootropics this past October. A snippet:

    “Certain people might benefit from certain combinations of certain things,” he told me. “But across populations, there is still no conclusive proof that substances of this class improve cognitive functions.” And with no way to reliably measure the impact of a given substance on one’s mental acuity, one’s sincere beliefs about “what works” probably have a lot to do with, say, how demanding their day was, or whether they ate breakfast, or how susceptible they are to the placebo effect.

    Nutrition, along with exercise and getting enough sleep, does play a role in Alzheimer’s and Dementia. The research does suggest that a diet higher in fruits and vegetables does help, but I’ve seen nothing suggesting that a full on vegetarian diet is best. Rather a Mediterranean diet, which primarily includes plant-based foods along with chicken and fish and limiting red meat to a few times a month, appears to be the advice given at the moment.

    As for sounding “preachy”, I didn’t take your comment that way and I hope you will not take my reply as a direct criticism as it is not intended as such.

    I don’t worry too much about alzheimer’s or dementia. Cancer tends to be what takes out members of my family. My great-grandmother on my mother’s side lived to 99 and had dementia in the last years. My grandmother on my mother’s side may have been suffering from dementia when she passed in her 70’s, but I believe it was cancer that did her in. (Could’ve been spite too, but that’s a long story.) My mother has made it to 84 and is doing well cognitively. Should I make it through my 70’s (not common among my relatives) I’m not too worried that I’ll lose my marbles. Right now I’m focusing on getting through 55 as that’s the age my biological father passed from, you guessed it, cancer.

  4. (apologies for the length of this)
    Fair enough.
    Penicillin was discovered by accident. Lucky for us that Fleming’s research was not predetermined results driven as it is today or we would not have had someone flexible minded enough to actually investigate penicillin.

    The bullshit factor in medicine is tilted to the bullshit side.
    You cannot trust most of what your doc says. The big media conglomerates (and there are 6 of them)each have ties to pharma companies. They distort and lie by omission.
    This is why you never hear about results showing 1% effectiveness of antidepressants, or 2% actual effectiveness of chemo.

    I have masters degrees in physics and math . I also have worked in biological research,and have witnessed the shift in science from inquiry to predetermined results bankrolled by corporations (ie corruption)..i could give you my history, but that doesn’t really matter. What matters are the facts…

    You might want to read
    Whole by a PhD researcher Campbell(the scientific Panels actually cover up nutrition knowledge)

    https://www.amazon.com/Whole-Rethinking-Nutrition-Colin-Campbell/dp/1939529840/ref=sr_1_2?keywords=Whole&qid=1553803181&s=gateway&sr=8-2

    Or Whitewash by a journalist
    https://www.amazon.com/Whitewash-Killer-Cancer-Corruption-Science/dp/1610918320/ref=sr_1_2?keywords=whitewash&qid=1553803166&s=gateway&sr=8-2

    These highlight how systematized scientific corruption has become.

    Pam Popper (an MD)on what happens to Whistleblowers in the industry.
    https://youtu.be/WkpYWQCJRzI

    And this is just the tip of the iceberg..”Science” has become corrupted by vested interests.
    Science, real science and its method are AMAZING.
    They are the most powerful tools we have, which is why it is sdo upsetting to see them appropriated by greedy people to push an agenda.

    ABOUT CANCER

    Dr Greger explaining some of the mechanics of fighting cancer with diet.
    https://youtu.be/0VX_oZBMSd4

    As Per China Study,you don’t have to eliminate meat/dairy just limit it to below ten percent of total caloric intake..and eat as many colorful fruits and veg as you can.
    There are cases that can inspire us all, like Ruth Heidrich, who beat 4th stage breast cancer that metastasized, and went on to be an ironman triathlete into her 80s.
    Or Chris_beat_cancer had stage IV colon cancer and came out alive.

    There is a reason biased studies and drugs with little benefit are given to the public. (effective Chemo rates are actually around 2%, which is why most MDs refuse treatment)

    Healthcare is roughly 20% of GDP(approx 19 Trillion) so around about $3.8 Trillion. If you cut that cost by 85% (which a healthy diet might be able to accomplish)what would happen to the economy?
    .

    (and it is not just the healthcare industry that is a sham, planned obsolescence is another scam run by industries, It is what killed the US car industry)
    Anyway, i am sure you have better things to do than listen to me jabbering on like some mad idjeet.

  5. There’s a lot to unpack in your reply. I’m a pretty cynical guy, but I can’t match your claim of “You cannot trust most of what your doc says.”

    I’ve been going to the same doctor for over 20 years now and I literally trust her with my life. Telling me I can’t believe most of what she says goes directly against my own lengthy personal experience. You will forgive me if I find your claim dubious as a result. It also puts into question the rest of the claims you make.

    I also do my best to keep up on what the current research is in all manner of scientific fields. I do not dispute that there are some scientists who work from a predetermined results driven stance, but that’s been true as long as science has existed. There will always be those who do it wrong because they think they already have the answers, but science is also largely a self-correcting system of knowledge. Yes, bad ideas can take hold for awhile, but in the long run it’s still the best system for understanding the world around us.

    The big media conglomerates (and there are 6 of them)each have ties to pharma companies. They distort and lie by omission.
    This is why you never hear about results showing 1% effectiveness of antidepressants, or 2% actual effectiveness of chemo.

    I’ve seen the claim that chemo is only 2% effective many times and the claim itself is based on a flawed study. Not to mention the fact that it’s a very broad claim considering that cancer comes in a variety of types, some of which chemo is very effective at treating and some of which it is not. If you’re curious enough to read a rebuttal of that claim you will find a good one by Dr. David Gorski at Science-Based Medicine.

    They also tackle the claims that antidepressants are no more effective than a placebo in an article by Dr. Harriet Hall here.

    On a personal level, I have friends and family who underwent chemo treatment and are still alive today as a result. I also have friends and family who underwent chemo treatment and it wasn’t effective and they stopped the treatment and went into hospice. I have enough confidence in it that if I developed cancer and my doctor thought chemo might be effective that I’d give it a shot and make future decisions based on how my cancer responded to it.

    Additionally, being married to a woman for nearly 20 years that has suffered from chronic depression, I have personal experience with the relief that the proper antidepressant can bring to someone suffering from this condition. It may take a bit to find the right drug/dosage, but the results are worth it. Not everyone responds to the same drugs the same way and not everyone needs drugs, but for those folks for whom they work they are life changing.

    Frankly, the claim that the media companies are in cahoots with the pharma companies is to sell you useless drugs is a conspiracy theory on par with the moon landings being faked. Which isn’t to say that some pharma companies haven’t done some dodgy shit in the name of profits, but to claim the industry as wholly corrupt requires more than a couple of links to convince me.

    I have masters degrees in physics and math . I also have worked in biological research,and have witnessed the shift in science from inquiry to predetermined results bankrolled by corporations (ie corruption)..i could give you my history, but that doesn’t really matter. What matters are the facts…

    I have no PHds in anything and I am fully aware of my amature status at understanding any of the science I read about, but your claims so far directly contradict my own experiences and the research of people I trust. I have no illusions that there is corruption within the medical industry as there is corruption in almost all human endeavors, but to claim it as a conspiracy on the scale that you are implying here beggars belief. I will take a look at the links you’ve provided, but your argument so far has left me skeptical at best.

    I have read T. Colin Campbell’s The China Study as well as the criticisms of it such as Dr. Harriet Hall’s review of the book and this series of articles by former raw vegan Denise Minger. I don’t think I have much need to check out “Whole” anytime soon.

    I’ve also heard of Dr. Michael Greger previously. Dr. Harriet Hall had a critique of his video Uprooting the Leading Causes of Death that was not kind and I trust Dr. Hall more than I trust Dr. Greger.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.