The Raving Atheist discusses The Worst Argument of All

Posted by Les on Wednesday, September 01, 2004 at 05:31 AM. Read 2898 times. Tags: ,
{name} pic

There’s a good entry up over at TRA titled The Worst Argument of All that takes a look at one of the more popular arguments theists like to throw at atheists as a reason why there must be a God.

“An atheist has no reason to oppose murder” is one of the religious bigot’s favorite canards. Dostoevsky’s dictum that “without God, anything is permitted” is popular among superstitious know-nothings who know nothing about atheism except that they hate it and its adherents. Without an all-powerful, celestial lawgiver to dispense reward and punishments, they argue, there’s no reason to be good. Why not just kill that old lady for her money, or for no reason at all, and simply hide the body?

The answer TRA provides is quite similar to one I’ve used on many occasions myself, but worded much more eloquently than I’ve ever managed. It’s definitely worth checking out and considering.

Speaking of The Raving Atheist, if you don’t read it regularly already then I highly recommend it. It’s simply one of the best written blogs about atheism I’ve ever seen and it’s a regular read of my own. I rarely comment there because there’s so little I disagree with or that I could add to the discussion most of the time and even to a long-time atheist such as myself who has given his non-belief a lot of thought over the years there’s still stuff that comes up on TRA that shows me a way of looking at myself I hadn’t considered previously. That alone keeps me coming back.

Comments:

Page 5 of 7 pages « First  <  3 4 5 6 7 >

Socialist Swine Canada Posted on 04/24/2005 at 01:32 AM

Socialist Swine pic

Gijn,

The fact that as hard as you try to shake the feeling they exist and still cannot is proof they exist.

I don’t have to shake the feeling that they exist.  I have no feeling that God, aliens, demons, or bogey-men exist.  I never really had those kinds of feelings ever.

Les United States Posted on 04/24/2005 at 05:02 AM

Les pic

Gijnabar’s last comment was just more preaching so I removed it. If I wanted to be preached to I’d go to church.

 Signature 

Gods dont kill people. People with Gods kill people. - David Viaene

GeekMom United States Posted on 04/24/2005 at 08:24 AM

GeekMom pic

But Smee loves Gijn anyway.  Whenever he does an act of intelligence and rationality, he’s actually doing it in Smee’s name.  But when G commits acts of sinful pride, obtuseness, self-delusion and preaching, he’s doing it in his imaginary little god Jehovah’s name.  But that’s okay, because Smee is not a jealous god, and he doesn’t care if you have any pretend gods before him, because he is a mature and rational god.

zilch Austria Posted on 04/24/2005 at 09:31 AM

zilch pic

Believing in God
whom Jesus revealed
Gij lives in a world
hermetically sealed.

 Signature 

You were born.  And so you’re free.  So happy birthday.
- Laurie Anderson

Gijnabar United States Posted on 04/24/2005 at 09:39 AM

Gijnabar pic

Les removed my last comment because I answered to Ingolfson’s feelings about the afterlife of the atheist. I should slow down a little on Les, because it is obviously starting to terrify him, just as he said I was of mice that are trying to steal my cheese.

I would like to now apologize for my shortcomings to you, I do not mean to be so abrupt. I lack patience and understandings.

Les thank you for your lessons, you have been a great source of inspiration for me. Corresponding with you has been very useful to me and you are what the ancients once refered to as a good soul.

I hope that I was not so offensive that you ban me altogether from posting on your site.

Please tell me more about my last post that you removed so I can better nderstand your rules.

zilch Austria Posted on 04/24/2005 at 10:14 AM

zilch pic

Gijn- I won’t presume to answer for Les, but speaking for the regulars here, we are interested in discussions about God and the nature of belief and disbelief, but not particularly interested in simply having the Bible quoted at us or being told we’re going to hell.  We’ve heard it all before, most of us know the Bible quite well, and it’s just not that edifying or even entertaining.  Have you checked out the archives here?

The trouble I see with trying to talk with believers such as you is that, as I tried to suggest in my little poem, your belief is a self-contained and sealed world that admits of no logical entrance.  Correct me if I’m wrong.  You believe:

Jesus/the Bible is the Truth
Anything that speaks against this Truth is the work of Satan
Therefore, knowledge is dangerous.

With such a standpoint, there’s not much middle ground to discuss logically, and logical discussion is what we’re interested in, not in simply hearing more fundamentalist blathering (no offence, but try to put yourself in our position).

Why do you believe that it is the Bible that is the Word of God, and not, say, the Koran or the Zendavesta or the Book of Smee?  Because the Christians got to you first, because of geographic proximity.  If you had been born in Arabia or Persia or Smeeland, you would have believed otherwise, and be bound to hell (if your current belief is correct).  A geographic accident- is that how God works?  Hard to believe.

 Signature 

You were born.  And so you’re free.  So happy birthday.
- Laurie Anderson

Spocko United States Posted on 04/24/2005 at 10:34 AM

Spocko pic

Truth can be found at The God FAQ!

zilch Austria Posted on 04/24/2005 at 10:45 AM

zilch pic

spocko- LOL

 Signature 

You were born.  And so you’re free.  So happy birthday.
- Laurie Anderson

PenetratingShaftOfTruthAndSemen United States Posted on 04/24/2005 at 11:43 AM

PenetratingShaftOfTruthAndSemen pic

Here’s my new avatar, do you like it?  I created it myself.

Les United States Posted on 04/24/2005 at 01:22 PM

Les pic

In retrospect I allowed my lack of sleep to make me cranky and I probably should’ve just ignored the comment rather than delete it. Gijn’s continuing insistence of knowing my feelings is part of what’s pissing me off. It’s the height of arrogance and his constant usage of it has convinced me he’s a troll and not a serious commenter. He’s here to stir up trouble and that’s all.

 Signature 

Gods dont kill people. People with Gods kill people. - David Viaene

GeekMom United States Posted on 04/24/2005 at 02:16 PM

GeekMom pic

If you had been born in Arabia or Persia or Smeeland, you would have believed otherwise, and be bound to hell (if your current belief is correct).  A geographic accident- is that how God works?  Hard to believe.

zilch, in the case of Smee, that would be Disneyland.  Everywhere you see the Sign of the Mouse, that is Smee’s realm.  He is everywhere.  All you have to do is believe, and He will reward you with a really nice dessert of your choice.

grin

elwedriddsche United States Posted on 04/24/2005 at 07:53 PM

elwedriddsche pic

Oh my, another fun thread I missed.

Was the “the seed is planted” card played yet?

 Signature 

Science is answers that must always be questioned.
Philosophy is questions that may never be answered.
Religion is answers that must never be questioned.
Politics is answers that lobbyists pay for.

TheBo$$ United States Posted on 04/24/2005 at 09:13 PM

TheBo$$ pic

Hey Ginj, pass the weed! Quit hogging it!

Ragman United States Posted on 04/24/2005 at 09:40 PM

Ragman pic

Was the “the seed is planted� card played yet?

No, but Ginja’s about as subtle as an alien face-hugger.

elwedriddsche United States Posted on 04/24/2005 at 10:02 PM

elwedriddsche pic

Well, just another troll and/or True Believer to provide some short-lived entertainment.

 Signature 

Science is answers that must always be questioned.
Philosophy is questions that may never be answered.
Religion is answers that must never be questioned.
Politics is answers that lobbyists pay for.

zilch Austria Posted on 04/25/2005 at 02:16 AM

zilch pic

Everywhere you see the Sign of the Mouse, that is Smee’s realm.  He is everywhere.  All you have to do is believe, and He will reward you with a really nice dessert of your choice.

Walt be praised, He’s even here in benighted Vienna!  You have to be mighty careful, though, about that dessert.  It could be a piece of Cheese in a Mousetrap set out by the Evil Duck.

 Signature 

You were born.  And so you’re free.  So happy birthday.
- Laurie Anderson

ingolfson Germany Posted on 04/25/2005 at 03:28 AM

ingolfson pic

But that’s okay, because Smee is not a jealous god,

I like him, GM. How do I pray to him?

zilch Austria Posted on 04/25/2005 at 03:36 AM

zilch pic

ingolfson, to pray to Smee, simply buy lots of Disney DVD’s.  And lots of Disney paraphenalia.  And lobby for a Disneyworld in Berlin.

 Signature 

You were born.  And so you’re free.  So happy birthday.
- Laurie Anderson

Gijnabar United States Posted on 04/25/2005 at 03:10 PM

Gijnabar pic

Well, just another troll and/or True Believer to provide some short-lived entertainment.

Followed by eternal damnation?

GeekMom United States Posted on 04/25/2005 at 03:31 PM

GeekMom pic

Followed by eternal damnation?

Nah, you won’t be damned, Gijn.  You’ll just push up the daisies like the rest of us.  Don’t worry about it.  Smee loves you.

Gijnabar United States Posted on 04/25/2005 at 03:46 PM

Gijnabar pic

Hey geekmom,
Thank you for your words of comfort, though even better than that I have been saved by Christ the Redeemer, yay!!
I love Jesus

What I meant by that last post was that the life of an atheist is short lived entertainment followed by an unsatisfying, meaningless death at the hands of Satan.

I wrote a post that was so scary to Les an atheist, that he had to take it down, I call it the “frightening censored post of death”.

Ask him to repost it and read it yourself if you got the guts.

Why are atheists afraid of death?
Death is when you move on to a higher state of being and should be looked forward to. Jesus tells us not to fear death, only fear being killed in Hell.

Gijnabar United States Posted on 04/25/2005 at 04:00 PM

Gijnabar pic

Death is when you move on to a higher state of being and should be looked forward to.

Oops, I was wrong. That only goes for those who repent for all their sins to the Lord Jesus Christ and are forgiven, but that’s not very hard to do and it’s way worth it. All you have to do is desire it.
He loves us all the same, because He made us, He is God. Jesus wants everyone to come to full repentence for there sins, He told me to tell you that.  smile

Spocko United States Posted on 04/25/2005 at 04:11 PM

Spocko pic

Well shucks, I shore be ascared uh dying an goin to hell an bein kilt an all! I bedduh fine me some Jezus rite kwiklike.

Qoayn United States Posted on 04/25/2005 at 04:34 PM

Qoayn pic

Why are atheists afraid of death?

Where the fuck did you get this? The only one even mentioning fear on the regular in this thread is you.

Satan has many forms and nothing stops him from taking the form of God fearing Christians..
...I am a recent born again and will add myself to your list of Gospel abiders who admit to you that it is only the fear of Hellfire that stays my hand from acts of sin, that is lust, bestiality(violence) and all others.

Killing, stealing, lying, lusting are all sins. So is pride, the fear of pain or death,..blah blah blah blah

Matthew 10:28 “Fear not them that can kill the body.... blah blah fear blah

Wait there’s more if you havnt had your fill yet..

He is God Almighty and Satan fears Him.

Im sure he does.

Do you believe that the fear of Hell has stopped many a crime? Do you realize that a person living by the word of the gospel is not capable of murder

and even more bullshit.. Im sure plenty of your so called “god fearing christians” little brains snap right in fucking half every day. Some die & some go to jail im sure.

all true God fearing Christians believe this.

im sure this theme isnt lost on any of us. nice sermen. quake you little sheep. quake you little bitches..

They fear and loathe the gospel as it has the power to remove them from you.

(this one was in with demon talk and more talk of ‘sin’)

fear Jesus and the Gospel.

brilliant conversion tactic you turd. “I am all powerful fear me”

Satan and his devils fear Jesus, so of course they do not want you to use it.

they do not.. I had a round with these guys last week at the waterfront and they said that it was all water under the bridge. They worked out a deal with god and they get to pick wich pussies they get to tourture in “the hereafter”. Honest, cross my heart and hope to fucking die if I’m lying. It was spookie-dookie.

..the people in power hated and feared Jesus back then


probably because he didnt know when to shut the fuck up..

Jesus tells us not to fear death, only fear being killed in Hell.

Hello.. Im dead already. try to kill me twice.. your gonna have to reincarnate me to kill me again prick. Im serious though, spouting shit like this is good for you.. if you kept it all in you might choke and run the risk of being killed again.

Honorable mention(s) in the category of “fear”:

For wit:

Do you lay awake at night fearing they’ll come and take away all your cheese?

and for using it first:

It almost seems like they’re uncomfortable to admit to fear of punishment as the primary moral motivator.

now this is useful:

Jimbo 1:2 Fear not the feline for she shall restrict the rat and the flea.

I am certain that if an atheist can exist on a day-to-day basis then they are quite in tune with their own mortality. I strongly doubt any of us fear an ominous looming end.

Gijnabar United States Posted on 04/25/2005 at 04:42 PM

Gijnabar pic

Ooayn RIP is not free and if you feel you did earn the right to rest in peace after you die, please tell me how you did that.

Page 5 of 7 pages « First  <  3 4 5 6 7 >

<< Back to main