Not all the email I get is from people who have somehow managed to wiggle free from their restraints and gain access to the computer at the nurse’s station when she isn’t looking. Quite a lot of it is very sincere and makes running SEB very worthwhile. Every now and then I get emails from folks, both atheist and believers, who are looking for some advice. This is one of those occasions.
A concerned Christian mother by the name of—we’ll call her “Mary” for our purposes here as she has requested anonymity—wrote me an email the other day about her fiancé’s rebellious daughter. The daughter is a bit of a hell raiser and uses the excuse that she’s an atheist to justify her actions. Here’s the email as I received it edited only for readability:
Hello Les,
My name is “Mary” and I want to pose a question to you and actually am hoping form some advice. Personally I am a Christian as is our family, my fiancé & his family…
My fiancé has a teen daughter who states she is an atheist, while I am doubtful she actually understands what this means…
You appear to be a very intelligent man with some viewpoints I found most interesting…
Here is a small piece of her history so that maybe you can help me understand and help her…
Before I start we did try counseling, she refused to speak…
This young lady lost her mother due to drug use and free sexuality which sent her mother to a grave at a way too early age… Her father, straight arrow…
The daughter, in my opinion, I feel chooses to believe in no God as it provides her with nothing else to fear or respect, teen rebellion combined with hurt anger and pain of a difficult life…
She is beyond sexually free, steals and defies her father continuously, all while stating she is an atheist. I have repeatedly told her that she should know, have knowledge of what she says before she says it. I told her that I was doubtful that people who are atheist throw all values out the window and more than likely many would take offense to her freely stating “this is atheism.”
I guess my question is....besides my telling her to research, which she won’t, how can I get it through to her that this is not true.... atheism is not a license for stealing, sexual promiscuity, and disrespect and lack of regard for people. I do not want to save a nation or a world, just one girl who is going to destroy herself.... being Christian and praying does not seem to be helping so I turn to you… stupid evil bastard (lol by the way sounds like something my brother would come up with)
Any time or advice is greatly appreciated and openly accepted.
Signed,
HELP,
I don’t want to be step mother to a deceased child.
“Mary”
Again this is a sincere request and I asked “Mary” if it would be OK for me to post this to SEB so you folks could chime in. What I’m hoping for is some constructive feedback for “Mary” as she is trying more than just praying to get through to what sounds like a troubled young woman. I know there are quite a few counselors and psychologists who lurk on this site so I’m hoping some of you may speak up as well. I also realize there’s not a whole lot in this email to go on so I’m not expecting anyone to have a perfect solution they can whip out and present her with—just some suggestions that might be helpful. I haven’t had a chance to write up a reply of my own yet, but I’m hoping to get something together this evening and I’ll post it in a comment if you guys are interested. In the meantime I’ll be passing along a link to this entry to “Mary” so she can follow along.


















The girl needs to understand that atheism does not and should never necessitate hurting oneself or others. I suspect, though, that she does at least partly understand this, and it may be that she is just a “problem child.” It’s not her fault, of course--she’s had anything but an easy life so far. Hopefully time will bestow more wisdom onto her.