There wasn’t a Jordan until it was carved out of eastern Mandate Palestine so Consi’s statement that “The Palestinians were not removed from Palestine.  They lived in Jordan.” Is far more untrue than anything LuckyJohn posted. But I’ve lurked here long enough to not expect Consi’s ‘facts’ to be real facts. Of course, according to Consi, zionist historian Benny Morris (and everyone else that is a legitimate historian) is probably the one lying, not Consi.

There wasn’t a Jordan until it was carved out of eastern Mandate Palestine

Miner, would you please tell the readers who governed eastern Mandate Palestine from its “inception” to its division? Also, please identify for them the time period that it was a nation-state, would you please?  You might do that by including that in a timeline.  The timeline might be helpful for the readers and could go from the time of recorded history until the present day, might you construct one for us?

Your answers will settle the accusations that you levied here.  I take offense at the accusations.  I have never intentionally misrepresented facts..  Not here, not anywhere.  You may take issue with my conclusions and the inferences I draw from the facts, which are my opinions, but you can go to the bank with the facts I state.

LJ:  There have been a litany of wrongs suffered by those on both sides.  As a result, compelling sympathetic arguments can be made for either side. As a result, there will be “historians” advocating a point of view.  My sole point was there was never a country of Palestine from which the Palestinians were expelled from in 1967 or 1948.

My sole point was there was never a country of Palestine from which the Palestinians were expelled from in 1967 or 1948.

No, but I’m sure they had another name for it back then. Something like “home”, I imagine. Regardless, as you say, wrongs have been done and suffered from both sides. Closure of the matter will not be an issue of who cedes blame, as finger-pointing seems to be the prime activity on the issue, and has had little success so far. The second most popular activity of “I am my people” - projection onto previous generations - has arguably made things worse.